Edinburgh Castle
Overview
No single building in Edinburgh carries more stories than the Castle. It has been besieged, held, lost and retaken more times than almost any fortress in Britain, and every century seems to have left something behind — a name, a wall with a hole in it, a sound that nobody can quite explain. We've drawn on three of its best-known threads for this excerpt: a gun that fires whether you believe in ghosts or not, a piper who is said never to have come back, and a set of tunnels that are equal parts documented history and pure rumour.
The One O'Clock Gun
Start with the one part of this story that isn't in dispute. Every day except Sunday, Good Friday and Christmas Day, a gun fires from the Castle's Mills Mount Battery at exactly 1pm — a tradition running continuously since 7 June 1861.[1][2] The idea came from Edinburgh businessman John Hewat, who had heard Paris's midday "petit canon" fire in the Jardin du Palais-Royal on a visit in 1846, and who spent the next fifteen years campaigning to bring the idea home.[2][3]
It was never tradition for its own sake. Ships anchored in the Firth of Forth needed a reliable way to set their chronometers for navigation, and Edinburgh already had a visual signal for this — a time ball, dropped daily from the top of the Nelson Monument on Calton Hill since 1852.[3] The trouble was fog, which the Forth has never been short of; a sound signal solved what the eye alone couldn't.[1][3] A cable over 4,000 feet long ran from Calton Hill to the Castle to keep gun and time ball synchronised to the same instant.[3]
The original gun was an 18-pounder fired from the Half Moon Battery; today it's a 105mm field gun, fired from Mills Mount since 2001 by a volunteer District Gunner of the 105th Regiment Royal Artillery.[2][3] By one well-repeated account it has only ever been fired in genuine anger once — in 1916, at German Zeppelins raiding the city during the First World War.[4] Otherwise it has sounded, uninterrupted, for over a hundred and sixty years: the one part of the Castle's daily life that keeps exact, secular time in a place that otherwise runs on rumour.
The Piper and the Tunnel
The best-known of the Castle's ghost stories concerns a set of tunnels, a boy, and a set of bagpipes. The story goes that a passage was found leading down from beneath the Castle, and that its explorers believed it might run all the way to Holyrood Palace, half a mile away at the foot of the Royal Mile.[5][6][7] Nobody was sure, and the tunnel was said to be too narrow for a grown man to pass through comfortably.
So, as the story is told, a boy piper was sent down instead, playing his pipes as he went so the route could be tracked from the streets above by ear. He made it some distance — most versions place him roughly under the Tron Kirk, about halfway down the Mile — before the music simply stopped.[6][8] A search party found no trace of him, and the tunnel entrance was later sealed.[8] Locals still say that on a quiet day, with the traffic down, you can catch the sound of bagpipes coming from somewhere beneath the street.[6]
"Stand on the Royal Mile near the Tron on a still evening, when the traffic thins, and listen. That's all this story has ever asked of anyone."
The Headless Drummer
Older than the piper, and tied to a specific date, is the story of the Headless Drummer Boy. In 1650, so the story goes, castle servants saw a small drummer circling the courtyard at night, beating out a march. On closer look, he had no head. He drummed through the night and was gone by morning.[9][10] Not long afterward, the Castle came under siege — Cromwell's forces took Edinburgh that same year, in the wake of his victory at Dunbar — and the boy's appearance was remembered ever after as a warning.[9][10] The belief that followed was straightforward: if the Drummer is seen again, the Castle is in danger.[9]
He hasn't been reported in the better part of four hundred years. Castle staff have, at various points, described hearing a faint, unexplained drumbeat along the ramparts at night — nothing more dramatic than that, but persistent enough that the story hasn't been allowed to fade.[10]
What Really Lies Beneath
Beneath the Castle lie its darkest rooms. From 1757 to 1814, its vaults beneath Crown Square held real prisoners of war — French, American, Spanish, Dutch, Irish, Italian, Danish and Polish, most of them sailors, some of them boys as young as six.[11][12] Conditions were exactly as bad as you'd expect: hundreds of men held in stone chambers built for a fraction of that number, most of it beneath the Great Hall and the Queen Anne Building.[12] Prisoners left their names, ships, and even an early version of the Stars and Stripes scratched into the vault doors — the graffiti is still there to see.[12]
And then, on the night of 12 April 1811, forty-nine of those prisoners hacked their way through the Castle's south wall and lowered themselves down the sheer face of Castle Rock on ropes.[13][14] All but one got clean away in the dark; every one was eventually recaptured, but the escape effectively ended the Castle's career as a working prison within three years.[11][14] The hole they cut is still there in the wall, and can still be pointed out from the ramparts.[11][12]
Hundreds of men spent years in those vaults, a long way from home. It would be strange if a place like that had nothing left to say.
Others Who Never Left
The piper and the drummer are the famous ones, but they are far from alone up there. Guides tell of a Grey Lady seen in the oldest parts of the Castle. Some say she is Janet Douglas, Lady Glamis, burned on the Castlehill in 1537 on a charge of witchcraft. Others say she is Mary of Guise, whose body lay in the Castle for months after her death in 1560. Sometimes she is said to wander. Sometimes she simply weeps.[20]
There is a less dignified ghost too: the Castle's unluckiest prisoner. As the story goes, he tried to escape by hiding in a barrow of muck, only for the barrow to be tipped over the battlements, with him in it. Visitors have reported a figure that smells strongly of manure, and a hand that tries to push them toward the edge.[20]
And then there is the dog. The Castle keeps a small cemetery for regimental mascots and soldiers' dogs, and some visitors say they have seen a scruffy black dog trotting about the grounds, belonging to nobody.[20]
The Night the Scientists Came
In April 2001, as part of the Edinburgh International Science Festival, psychologist Dr Richard Wiseman ran one of the largest ghost hunts ever attempted. Some 240 volunteers, screened so they knew nothing of the local stories, were led through the dark and asked to note anything they felt: a sudden chill, a sense of someone watching, a touch on the arm.[15][16] In the rooms that already had a haunted reputation, around half of them reported something. In the rooms that didn't, only about a third did.[15] Wiseman, a sceptic by trade, put it down to draughts, lighting and the size of the rooms. He still admitted the pattern was there.[16][18]
The experiment is nearly always remembered as a night at the Castle, though the published study took place in the South Bridge Vaults, half a mile down the hill.[18][19] We tell that side of it in Underground Edinburgh.
"People reported far more experiences in the vaults which were allegedly haunted... it shows there is something going on."
Why the Story Persists
Edinburgh Castle has stood long enough, and been fought over often enough, that every kind of story has had time to take root there. A gun that keeps exact time. A drummer who only comes when danger does. A boy whose pipes are still listened for under the street. Prisoners, a lady in grey, a dog nobody owns. Few places in Scotland have had so many people die in them, wait in them, or fail to leave them. It would be odd if none of them stayed.
What We Draw From This
There's a lot to work with here: a drum, a set of pipes, the shape of the Rock itself. We started with the pipes. The Lone Piper is one of our Well-Kent, Edinburgh's named ghosts that we keep in stock: white, wound round with bands of red and blue like a plaid, falling differently on every one.
References
- Edinburgh Castle official blog — "The Origins of the One O'clock Gun"
- Edinburgh Castle official site — "One o'clock Gun"
- Edinburgh Castle Tickets guide — "The One O'Clock Gun at Edinburgh Castle: Daily at 1pm"
- Mercat Tours — "11 Facts About Edinburgh's One o'Clock Gun"
- DiscoverKelpies — "The Ghostly Piper of Edinburgh Castle"
- Great Castles — "Ghosts of Edinburgh Castle"
- Transceltic — "The Ghost of the Missing Edinburgh Piper Boy"
- My Macabre Roadtrip — "Is Edinburgh Castle Haunted?"
- Folklore Scotland — "The Headless Drummer Boy"
- Mercat Tours — "3 Dark Legends of Edinburgh Castle"
- Edinburgh Castle official site — "History of the Castle"
- Edinburgh Castle official site — "Prisons of War"
- Retrospect Journal — "Napoleonic Prisoners and Edinburgh Castle: A Brief Examination"
- Edinburgh Castle official blog — "Ten Epic Attempts to Escape Edinburgh Castle"
- ABC News (2001) — coverage of the Edinburgh International Science Festival ghost experiment
- Edinburgh News (Scotsman) — "When a Scientist Tried to Prove Edinburgh Castle Was Haunted"
- All That's Interesting — "Haunted Castles: 9 Ghostly Fortresses Around The World" (citing The Guardian)
- Wiseman, Watt, Stevens, Greening & O'Keeffe (2003) — "An Investigation into Alleged 'Hauntings'", British Journal of Psychology, 94(2), 195–211
- Full text (PDF) — confirms South Bridge Vaults and Hampton Court Palace as the study sites
- Mercat Tours — "Edinburgh Castle Ghosts"
See the Edinburgh ghosts we've made so far →
Filed under Dayligaun's ongoing series, Excerpts from the Archives
Dayligaun · Workshop in East Lothian