Deacon Brodie
Overview
By day, William Brodie made fine furniture for the best houses in Edinburgh, fitted their locks, and sat on the town council. By night, he let himself back into those same houses with keys he had quietly copied, and robbed them. For years nobody suspected a thing.
He was hanged in front of the Tolbooth in 1788, on a gallows he liked to boast he had designed. His friends carried his body away in a cart, hoping to bring him back to life. Within a few years people were saying they had seen him in Paris. And on the Lawnmarket, they say he still rides out of the close that bears his name on a horse breathing fire.
The Deacon
Brodie was born on 28 September 1741, the son of Francis Brodie, a prosperous wright and cabinetmaker on the Lawnmarket. The family house stood in what is now Brodie's Close, with the workshops and timber yard at the bottom of it.[1] William followed his father into the trade, and when the old man died in 1782 he inherited the business and a good deal of money.[1][4]
He also followed him into civic life. Like his father, he became Deacon of the Incorporation of Wrights, the head of his trade, and with it came a seat on the town council.[1][2] His work was good. A cabinet he made is said to have stood at the foot of the young Robert Louis Stevenson's bed, and it survives today in the Writers' Museum, a few steps from the close.[5][9] A notice put out in 1788 describes him as about five feet four, slender, and looking younger than his age.[1]
By Night
The money never lasted. Brodie gambled, with dice and on the cockfights, and he was a regular at Clark's tavern at the head of Fleshmarket Close.[1][4] He kept two mistresses, Anne Grant and Jean Watt, in separate houses, with three children by one and two by the other. Neither seems to have known about the other.[1]
His trade gave him the answer. A cabinetmaker and locksmith goes in and out of wealthy houses and shops, and in Brodie's day it was common to hang the door key on a nail just inside. He would press it into a lump of putty, take the impression home, and cut a copy.[1][2] With a small gang — George Smith, a locksmith; Andrew Ainslie; and John Brown — he went back after dark.[1][3] A jeweller's shop on the Bridges. A silk merchant's. Even the University of Edinburgh's silver mace went missing.[1][3]
The Excise Office
The last job was the biggest. On the night of 5 March 1788 the gang broke into the General Excise Office for Scotland in Chessel's Court, off the Canongate, expecting the King's revenue. Brodie kept watch. When one of the Excise officials, James Bonar, came back to the building late, the plan fell apart, and they got away with only a few pounds.[1][3]
The gang unravelled within days. Brown went to the authorities. Smith and Ainslie were taken, and before long they were talking too.[1][2] On Sunday 9 March, Brodie left Edinburgh. He reached London, crossed to the Low Countries, and made his way to Amsterdam, meaning to sail for America.[1]
He might have made it, but he had handed some letters to a fellow traveller to post home, and the man passed them to the Sheriff. The trail led to Amsterdam, where Brodie was found hiding in a cupboard in an alehouse, on the eve of his voyage.[1] He was back in Edinburgh by 17 July.[1]
A Leap in the Dark
Brodie and Smith were tried together on 27 and 28 August 1788, with Lord Braxfield presiding and Henry Erskine, the most famous advocate in Scotland, speaking for the Deacon.[1][4] The court sat through the night. At one in the afternoon the jury came back, and found both men guilty.[1]
In the Tolbooth he was chained by one foot, with a chain long enough to reach a writing table. He drew a draughts board on the floor and played against himself.[1] He kept his clothes immaculate to the end.
On 1 October 1788 he walked out to the scaffold in front of the Tolbooth in a handsome black suit, his hair powdered. The rope was wrong, and twice he stepped down to chat with friends while the hangman fixed it.[1] Then it was done. Brodie had liked to boast that he had designed this new drop himself, and the newspapers repeated it.[1] So it is said that the Deacon was one of the first to try out his own gallows.
That was not quite the end. A French doctor, Peter Degravers, had visited him in prison and promised to revive him. The hangman was paid to keep the drop short. Once the body was cut down, it was put in a cart and driven around the Castle, then carried into a workshop on the Lawnmarket, where the doctor tried to bleed it back to life.[1] It didn't work. Or so the story goes.
Primary Accounts
The trial was published in full, with letters and accounts from the time, and much of Brodie's own voice survives.
Found hiding in the cupboard in Amsterdam, Brodie was told simply to "come along with me". He saw there was no use resisting, and went.
Asked about the scaffold, Brodie called it "a leap in the dark". When he heard that other prisoners had been given six more weeks, he turned to Smith: "George, what would you and I give for six weeks longer?"
Years later, Robert Louis Stevenson remembered the cabinet at the foot of his childhood bed as "a very pretty piece of work". He had grown up sleeping beside the Deacon's handiwork.
"He made the cabinets, fitted the locks and sat on the council. Then he came back at night with the keys. No wonder Edinburgh never quite let him go."
Still Riding
Brodie was buried in an unmarked grave in the kirkyard of what is now Buccleuch Parish Church.[1][2] It is said that when the grave was later opened, there was no trace of him inside. Plenty of people in Edinburgh believed the doctor had succeeded, that the Deacon had slipped out of Scotland, and some claimed to have met him and talked with him in Paris.[1][3]
If he did escape, he seems to have come home. Legend has it that the ghost of William Brodie appears in his own close on the Lawnmarket, riding a demonic, fire-breathing horse. He rides the length of the close that bears his name, and then horse and rider ride off into hell.[6] Others say he walks the Royal Mile, still angry at the way it all ended.[8]
Across the road, at Deacon Brodie's Tavern, drinkers have spoken of shadowy figures on the stairs and sudden cold near the back of the building, and staff of finding things moved after closing time. The alley opposite has its own reputation, with visitors describing a sudden chill and the feeling of being followed.[7]
Why the Story Persists
Stevenson never forgot the Deacon. He and W. E. Henley wrote a play about him, Deacon Brodie, or the Double Life, and Brodie is very often named as one of the Edinburgh men behind Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde, the respectable gentleman with a monster inside.[2][4][5] Stevenson himself never said so outright.[5]
He had good company on the Lawnmarket. More than a century earlier, just a few doors along at the head of the West Bow, lived Major Thomas Weir, another pillar of the town with a secret life.[4] Edinburgh, it seems, has always had a soft spot for a double life.
A Note on the Record
The gallows story is the one everybody tells. The council's own records show the new drop was ordered in 1785 and paid for to another deacon, so William Roughead, who edited the trial, called the tale that Brodie built and first tried out his own gallows "a picturesque improvement on the literal truth". He allowed that Brodie may have designed the model.[1] The famous steel collar he is said to have worn under his shirt doesn't appear in the account of the time. That account has the French doctor and a short rope instead.[1]
What We Draw From This
We've made a Deacon of our own, and he has joined the Well-Kent, Edinburgh's named ghosts that we keep in stock. He wears two faces: respectable pale green and peach for the councillor, and on one side a bright patch of red, yellow and blue for the life he kept out of sight.
Brodie's Close and his tavern are both on our map of Haunted Edinburgh.
References
- William Roughead (ed.) — Trial of Deacon Brodie (Notable Scottish Trials, 1906; Project Gutenberg)
- Historic UK — "Deacon Brodie"
- Escape the Past — "Introducing Edinburgh's Real-life Jekyll & Hyde"
- Edinburgh and the Lothians — ch. XVI, "Two Edinburgh Criminals" (Electric Scotland)
- Atlas Obscura — the Brodie cabinet and Jekyll and Hyde
- Spooky Isles — "The Royal Mile: A Guide to Ghosts and Hauntings"
- Spooky Isles — "Deacon Brodie's Tavern: The Dark History Behind Edinburgh's Gentleman Thief"
- Edinburgh News — "11 haunted Edinburgh pubs where ghostly figures roam"
- Edinburgh Expert — "Edinburgh's Infamous Deacon Brodie: The Original Split Personality"
See the Edinburgh ghosts we've made so far →
Filed under Dayligaun's ongoing series, Excerpts from the Archives
Dayligaun · Workshop in East Lothian