Burke and Hare
Overview
The West Port no longer looks the way it did in 1828. Tanner's Close is gone, built over more than a century ago, and the lodging house at the bottom of it exists now only in old surveys and older testimony. But no story out of the Old Town is repeated with more grim precision than this one. Sixteen people walked into the West Port that year and never walked out. Some of the Grassmarket's oldest drinking rooms are said to have kept a few of them since.
The Men
William Burke and William Hare were Irish labourers who had come to Scotland to work on the Union Canal. When the work ended, Burke turned to cobbling and Hare to keeping a lodging house in Tanner's Close, in the West Port — a cramped, overcrowded corner of the Old Town where a stranger could arrive, and disappear, without much notice taken either way.
The Trade
It began, by Burke's own account, with a body that was never murdered at all. An elderly lodger of Hare's — known to history only as "Old Donald" — died owing rent in late 1827. Rather than lose the money, the two men sold his body to Dr Robert Knox, an anatomist whose private lectures were among the most sought-after in Edinburgh's medical schools, for the better part of eight pounds. It was more money than either man had ever held at once.
What followed, over the roughly ten months that came after, was at least sixteen further deaths — men and women, mostly poor, mostly people the two men judged would not be missed. Their method left almost nothing for a doctor to find: one man restraining the victim's chest while the other covered nose and mouth, until it was over. It became known, in the years after, simply as Burking.
The Victims
Most of the sixteen are known only in outline — poor, often itinerant, chosen because Burke and Hare judged, usually correctly, that no one would come looking. A few are remembered more fully. Mary Paterson, a young woman killed that spring, was recognised on Dr Knox's dissection table by students who had seen her alive only days before — recognised, and dissected anyway. James Wilson, known locally as "Daft Jamie," was a familiar figure on Edinburgh's streets, well liked despite a disability that made him instantly recognisable; Knox is said to have had his body dissected unusually quickly, and his head and feet removed, once the resemblance became a problem.
It was this shift — from strangers nobody would miss to people the city actually knew by sight — that began to draw notice long before Margaret Docherty's death brought the whole trade down.
The Unravelling
It ended, as these things tend to, with the one victim they were careless about. On Hallowe'en 1828, Margaret Docherty was killed in the lodging house while other tenants slept under the same roof. Two of them, Ann and James Gray, grew suspicious when Docherty vanished overnight and found her body hidden beneath a bed. They went to the police.
Burke and Hare were arrested within days. There was no forensic proof to convict either man of murder outright, so the Crown made Hare an offer: immunity, in exchange for the truth. He took it, and gave the details of all sixteen deaths. Burke stood trial that Christmas Eve, was found guilty of Docherty's murder, and was sentenced to hang. Burke's partner, Helen McDougal, faced the same charge and walked free on a "not proven" verdict — Scots law's third option, reserved for a jury convinced of guilt but not quite convinced enough to say so outright.
Primary Accounts
Unlike most of our excerpts, this one has real courtroom testimony and contemporary record behind it — not modern retelling, but the words of people who were there at the time.
Burke's own confession, given awaiting execution, denied the one crime he was never accused of: he insisted that neither he nor Hare ever robbed a grave, and that every body but the first had been a killing, not a find.
Dr Robert Christison, the forensic physician who examined the case, considered Dr Knox "deficient in principle and in heart" — though he stopped short of finding him legally culpable.
"Up the close and doon the stair, but and ben wi' Burke and Hare. Burke's the butcher, Hare's the thief, Knox the boy that buys the beef." A rhyme of unknown authorship, sung by Edinburgh children in the years after the trial and still quoted in histories of the case today.
What Followed
Burke was hanged at the Lawnmarket on the 28th of January 1829, before a crowd said to number in the tens of thousands. In a piece of justice few missed the irony of, his own body was handed over for dissection. His skeleton remains on display at Edinburgh's Anatomical Museum to this day.
Hare, having bought his freedom with Burke's, vanished from Edinburgh entirely — his later life is one of the few parts of the story nobody has ever been able to agree on. One account has him blinded and reduced to begging on the streets of London; another has him quietly settling in Dumfries, or returning to Ireland. No record has ever settled the question either way.
Dr Knox was never charged, though Edinburgh never forgave him either. A crowd burned an effigy of him outside his home within weeks of the trial, and though he continued lecturing for a time, the city's medical establishment gradually froze him out; he left for London within a few years and never really recovered his standing. The case itself fed directly into the public argument that led to the Anatomy Act of 1832 — the law that finally gave British medical schools a legal supply of bodies for dissection, ending the trade that had made Burke and Hare's business possible in the first place. It wasn't the only case behind that reform, but it was, by most historians' account, the one that made the argument impossible to ignore.
The Ones Who Stayed
A short walk from where Tanner's Close stood is the White Hart Inn, on the Grassmarket, often called the oldest pub in the city. It is widely named as one of the places Burke and Hare went looking for company: lonely drinkers, a little worse for wear, who could be talked into one more dram back at the lodging house.[9][10]
Whether or not they ever stood at its bar, the White Hart has gathered ghosts of its own. Staff have told of footsteps crossing the floor upstairs long after the doors are locked. One paranormal investigation is said to have caught a voice on a recording, repeating "help me, help me". In the cellar, one witness described seeing a pair of legs on their own, and then the whole figure they belonged to.[9] Five centuries of drinkers have passed through those rooms. Not all of them, the stories say, have entirely left.[10]
And Burke himself has never quite left the city. As well as his skeleton, a small pocketbook said to be bound in his own skin is kept at Surgeons' Hall Museums.[11] You can find the White Hart, and the West Port, on our map of Haunted Edinburgh.
What We Draw From This
The West Port is among the places we've long considered for a future collection — though what shape such a Ghost might take, and whether it could ever be made with the right restraint, remains an open question. We're in no hurry to answer it. If we ever do, the Register goes first.
References
- Wikipedia — "Burke and Hare murders"
- National Library of Scotland — "From Crime to Collection: Burke and Hare at the Library"
- University of Edinburgh, College of Medicine & Veterinary Medicine — "Burke and Hare"
- EdinburghGuide.com — "Burke and Hare"
- CrimeReads — "The Sinister History of Medical Serial Killers" (2024)
- Lisa Rosner, The Anatomy Murders: Being the True and Spectacular History of Edinburgh's Notorious Burke and Hare (University of Pennsylvania Press)
- Escape the Past — "Who were Burke & Hare? Edinburgh's Infamous Body Snatchers"
- My Macabre Road Trip — "Burke and Hare: The True Story Behind Edinburgh's Most Notorious Murders"
- The Scotsman Food & Drink — "6 of the scariest haunted pubs in Edinburgh"
- Everything Edinburgh — "The White Hart Inn: Edinburgh's Oldest Pub"
- Everything Edinburgh — "Burke and Hare: Edinburgh's Bodysnatching Murders"
See the Edinburgh ghosts we've made so far →
Filed under Dayligaun's ongoing series, Excerpts from the Archives
Dayligaun · Workshop in East Lothian